Crafting Robust Shareholder Agreements: Beyond the Basics

The Atom Team

When forming a startup or entering into a business partnership, one of the foundational elements is having a solid shareholder agreement. Suraj Rana, fondly known as Mischa of Sole Legal Services emphasises that a shareholder agreement is not merely a document that outlines ownership percentages. It is a comprehensive contract that can protect the enterprise’s interests and provide a clear framework for resolving potential disputes. 

Let’s dive into more insights on shareholder agreements:

Key Provisions in a Shareholder Agreement

  • Ownership and Shares: The agreement must detail the share distribution among stakeholders and address how ownership percentages will change as the business grows or if additional investors come on board.
  • Pre-emption Rights and Drag-Along Clauses: These ensure existing shareholders have the right to buy new shares before outside investors can acquire them. They may require minority shareholders to join in the sale if the majority wish to sell their stakes.
  • Decision Making and Control: Clearly outlines the decision-making processes, including how board decisions are made, voting rights, and what happens if there’s a deadlock.
  • Roles and Responsibilities: Don’t get bogged down in minutiae and outline the primary duties of key individuals can prevent confusion and disputes regarding operational roles.

Exit Strategies and Resolution

A crucial component of a shareholder agreement is the exit strategy. This part must define the terms of share sales upon someone’s departure from the company, distinguishing between ‘good leavers’ and ‘bad leavers’. It’s recommended that the company should have the option to buy back shares possibly at the price the exiting shareholder paid for them, which can be vital when managing an unforeseen exit of a stakeholder.

Securing the Long-Term Commitment

Vesting schedules are another tool to establish clear timelines for when shares are owned outright by stakeholders. This can encourage commitment to the company and provide a mechanism to protect the business should partnerships dissolve prematurely.

Embracing the Future

As a business prepares for new investment rounds, the shareholder agreement will often need to be reevaluated and possibly redrafted. This ensures clarity around what happens to the ownership percentages when new equity is introduced, and how this aligns with existing shareholder rights detailed in the agreement.

Prelude to Drafting the Agreement

It’s important to have of thorough communication among all potential shareholders prior to creating their agreement. Founders should:

  • Engage in detailed discussions about the direction of the business, ownership, roles, and expectations.
  • Review their business plan and intentions for growth, including future employee share options.
  • Consult with professionals, like accountants and lawyers, to ensure that the agreements align with both commercial and legal best practices.

When Things Go South: Handling Disputes and Protecting Interests

For those unfortunate situations where a former stakeholder becomes a problem, having clear clauses in the agreement regarding share buy-backs and protocols for selling shares after an exit is essential. This ensures the business can continue to run smoothly without being hindered by individuals no longer active in the company’s operations or aligned with its goals.

Final Thoughts: A Living Document

Creating a shareholder agreement is not a one-time event, but rather an ongoing process that may evolve as the business grows and changes. It is a safeguard to assure that regardless of the dynamics among shareholders, the business has a robust framework in place to manage changes and challenges effectively. Insights into shareholder agreements underscore the importance of combining legal precision and commercial awareness, tailoring the agreement to the unique needs of each enterprise while safeguarding its longevity and prosperity.

For the full episode, tune in at this link.

We’ll be your virtual Chief Technology Officer
Whether faith in the existing team has been eroded, your current tech team needs a senior mentor, or you need a new tech vision for the company, Atom CTO is here to support you.